Architectural Record: National Museum of African American History and Culture
November 1, 2016
The freestanding building, occupying five acres on the last available spot on the National Mall in Washington, D.C., is both monument and museum -- and memorial, according to its designer, David Adjaye, who, with Phil Freelon, led the four-firm architectural team of Freelon Adjaye Bond/SmithGroupJJR. "This story has embedded in it so much complexity that it's not just about telling that story," says Adjaye. "This is more than a functional building to hold content but also a representative building -- I felt compelled to find symbolism that would start to make a connection, but symbolism that wasn't too dogmatic. One that was definitely not familiar immediately but would make you ask questions."
The museum's story starts in Africa, and Adjaye's symbol is the corona, a three-tiered crown used in Yoruban art from West Africa. (The actual sculpture that served as inspiration for Adjaye is on five-year loan to NMAAHC from the Haus der Kunst in Munich and is displayed in the uppermost gallery.) The 250,000 square feet of facade that take on that shape are covered in a latticework of bronze-colored cast-aluminum panels that recall celebrated historical patterns by black ironworkers in the South.
The building's compact exterior belies the sprawling galleries contained within. The structure extends as deep below grade as it rises above -- just over 60 feet. In fact, visitors are encouraged to begin their tour at the very bottom. There, the history galleries begin in dark rooms with the story of slavery.
The building's location is not far from the site where slaves arrived by boat in the nation's capital, a center for the domestic slave trade. Built on swampy land where the Tiber Creek once flowed, the entire foundation had to be reengineered when the support for the excavation wall failed. "We encountered similar issues at the Museum of the American Indian on the opposite end of the Mall, but this area of the Washington Monument grounds was much more susceptible to the high water table," says Hal Davis of Smith GroupJJR. "The excavated area contained too much degradable material and large boulders that interrupted the integrity of the wall, creating opportunities for water to get through." The new foundation comprises a bathtub-like waterproofing system, with additional piles to tie down the slabs.
The exhibition opens up into a cavernous space as you ascend the ramping history galleries, passing large installations like a Jim Crow–era railroad passenger car and a plane, soaring overhead, used by the Tuskegee Airmen. NMAAHC is, in fact, a vertical museum, spanning multiple levels. As you approach grade, the contemplative court, with its circular cascade of water, offers a moment of reflection, and rest. The adjacent cafeteria offers up soul food.
Aboveground, the structure of the museum is more like that of a bridge than a building. The floors and facade -- both the metal panels and the glass behind them -- hang off four rectangular concrete-and-steel cores (which contain vertical transportation, restrooms, and mechanical space) toward the corners of the building, which have varying dimensions but are roughly 40 feet long. The entire building is supported by a steel superstructure that spans between those four cores -- a convenient reference as well to the four "pillars" upon which NMAAHC metaphorically stands, which include the celebration and sharing of the museum's content.
As a place, the museum is not to be missed. The notion that a place like this -- a national commemoration of black history -- did not exist before is astounding. As architecture, it is not beyond reproach. While on the outside it handsomely -- and proudly -- stands out against its white neoclassical neighbors, its interiors, with escalators and terrazzo flooring, leave you feeling as if you are at a mall, not on the Mall. Ralph Applebaum's exhibition design, so moving inside the history galleries below grade, at times borders on kitsch within the busy installations of upper-level galleries that celebrate African-American achievements in music, sports, literature, and pop culture. The vast 22-foot-high heritage hall, which serves as the lobby on the ground floor, feels too empty, too corporate. One wonders if the idea for a forest of columns hanging from the ceiling -- part of Adjaye's original concept for that space but eliminated partly to save costs, and partly to display art instead -- would have alleviated that sense.
Where the interiors excel are in the space between the facade and the enclosed galleries on the upper levels that allows dappled light to filter in from the metal screens. According to Adjaye, "Going out into that corridor, into that light-filled space, and then going back into this sort of dark box is an important part of keeping you engaged as you go up the building." Indeed, as one completes the journey and reaches the lookout at the uppermost gallery, with its views over the capital city, there is a sense of triumph for this ongoing story and how it is told through the architecture of this building.
By Josephine Minutillo